Identity crisis after job loss, and who you are without the title

Losing a job can take your sense of self with it. Why that hurts so much, what the title was covering, and how a hard ending can become a real beginning.

By Robert Simic · 24 September 2020

The laptop was taken back on a Tuesday. The badge stopped working on Wednesday. By Thursday the emails had stopped coming, and on Friday morning you woke at the usual time, reached for your phone out of habit, and found that nobody needed you for anything at all.

It's a strange silence. Part of it is fear, and fear with good reason: bills don't stop arriving because your salary did. But under the fear there's something harder to name. At a dinner last weekend someone asked you what you do, and you didn't know how to answer. For years that question had a clean, respectable reply. Now there's a pause, and in the pause, a feeling like standing in a coat that's been taken off you.

That's not just job loss. That's an identity, suddenly without its costume.

Why does losing a job cause an identity crisis?

Losing a job causes an identity crisis because the role had become an answer to who am I. The title, the routine and the sense of being needed held your identity together. When they go, the question they answered returns all at once. The crisis is painful, but it's also an opening to meet who you are under any role.

That second sentence is the one I want you to hold on to. Not because it makes the fear go away. It doesn't. But because it's true, and I know it from the inside.

What does it feel like when the job was who you were?

Like being introduced without a name.

Somewhere along the way you were handed a set of costumes to get through. The competent one. The provider. The one with the good job. For many people the professional role becomes the finest costume they own. It's how they earn respect, how they structure their day, how they answer every stranger at every party. Over years, the costume stops feeling like something you wear and starts feeling like skin.

So when it's taken away, it feels like being skinned. Not only has your income gone, but the way you knew yourself has gone with it. People describe it as disorientation more than sadness. They don't know what to do with a Tuesday. They don't know who to be in their own kitchen at eleven in the morning.

This is what a survival identity looks like when it's suddenly out of work. It isn't you. But it's been doing the job of being you for so long that its absence feels like a hole.

If that hole is what you're standing in right now, hear this clearly. You are not broken. You are buried, under a role that was never big enough to hold you.

Have you been through this yourself?

Yes, and it nearly finished me.

I moved to the other side of the world, to South Africa, and finally built what I thought was a secure income. And then I was retrenched, which is just a polite word for fired with nothing. I'd already left my home country after a war. I'd washed cars and worked night shifts to get that far. Losing the job wasn't just losing money. What followed was one of the hardest stretches of my life, and I don't romanticise it.

But I can tell you now what I couldn't have believed then. That loss turned out to be the beginning of the road that led me to this work, and to the life I have today. Not because losing a job is secretly good. Because it forced the question the job had been answering for me, and the real answer was far better than the title had ever been. You can read more of that story on my page.

Is losing a job really a loss?

The money and the security are real losses, and they deserve real, practical attention. Take the steps you need. Talk to the people who can help with the practical side. None of what follows replaces that.

But ask yourself a harder question, too. If the job was one you did to pay the bills, if it never energised you, never felt meaningful to your spirit, never felt like a calling, then was the job itself the thing you've lost? Or was it the costume, and the safety of knowing who to be?

For many people, the uncomfortable truth is that the job was never really theirs. They took it because it was sensible. They stayed because it was safe. And now, for the first time in their adult life, they have the space to ask what they actually want, and who they actually are.

How can I start to separate myself from the role?

Try this over the next day or two. It's simple, and it's more powerful than it sounds.

When someone asks what you do, or when you ask yourself, notice what happens in your body before you answer. A tightening? A flush of shame? A need to explain?

Then, privately, try answering a different question instead. Not what do I do, but what was I doing when I felt most like myself? Maybe it was teaching someone a skill. Solving a problem nobody else could. Making people laugh in a tense meeting. Building something from nothing. Write down whatever comes.

You'll probably notice something. None of those answers is a job title. They're qualities, and they're yours. Nobody took them back with the laptop. They were never part of the job. The job was just one place you happened to use them.

Keep the list somewhere you'll see it. On the hard mornings, and there will be some, it's a quiet reminder that the thing you're looking for isn't a title. It's a place to be this person again, and there are far more of those places in the world than there are job openings.

What comes after the crisis?

Often, a truer life than the one before.

This is where the old word I've used for years comes in. The invitation of a moment like this is to unbecome who you weren't, and become who you always were, deeply inside. To let the learned limitations fall away along with the badge. That's what it means to unbecome, and a job loss, painful as it is, can be one of the most direct doors into it.

Some people come out of a redundancy into work they'd secretly wanted for twenty years. Others take a similar job again, but go into it as a different person, no longer needing it to tell them who they are. Either way, the change that matters isn't the next title. It's that they found the one underneath all titles, the one the question who am I was pointing at all along.

Where do I start while everything feels uncertain?

With one clear conversation, before you rush into the next role.

Sara, our veteran RS Method Master Coach, holds free mentoring sessions for exactly this kind of moment. No pitch, no script. Just a calm, clear look at what's actually happening underneath the fear, so your next decision comes from who you are rather than from panic.

You lost a job. You didn't lose yourself. You may be about to meet yourself properly for the first time.

Robert Simic, guiding the remembering.

Questions

What people also ask.

01 Why does losing a job feel like losing myself?

Because for many people the job became part of their identity: a title that answered who am I, and a structure that held their days. When it goes, the question it was answering comes back all at once.

02 Is it normal to grieve a job I didn't even love?

Yes. You can grieve the security, the routine and the identity even if the work itself never fed you. Grief and relief can sit side by side, and both are allowed.

03 How do I rebuild my sense of self after being laid off?

Rather than rushing to rebuild a new title, look at what the old one was covering. Who you are underneath any role is still here, and it's a far steadier foundation than the next job.

04 What about the money worries?

They're real and they deserve practical attention. Take the practical steps you need. The inner work sits alongside them, not instead of them, and it often makes the practical decisions clearer.

Your next step

Talk it through with Sara

A free 30-minute Zoom with a veteran RS Method Master Coach. No pitch.

Talk it through with Sara →

Keep reading

The room remembers everyone who walks in.

- Robert Simic
guiding the remembering