Many people feel they don't belong anywhere because they've spent years fitting in instead: learning each group's words, jokes and habits well enough to pass. Fitting in can win you a place in the room and still leave the person who earned it standing outside. If the feeling comes with low mood, a dread of people or thoughts of harming yourself, see a doctor first.
Giedre spent most of October watching a series she doesn't much like.
Four seasons of it, two episodes a night, on a laptop balanced on her knees in bed. The hiking group she joined in the spring quotes it all the time: in the car, on the trail, in the group chat. She wanted to understand the jokes.
Now it's the group's first weekend away. They've rented a farmhouse near the foot of the mountains in Ras Al Khaimah, and nine of them are sitting round a fire pit with paper plates on their knees. Somebody burns the halloumi. Somebody else says the famous line from season three, and the whole circle laughs.
Giedre laughs too. She knows the line now. She could tell you the episode.
And sitting there in the warmth, inside the joke for the first time, she feels further from these people than she did in April, when she understood none of it.
Later, in a bunk room full of sleeping hikers, she tries to recall what she used to watch before anyone was asking. Only the series comes to mind.
Why do I feel like I don't belong anywhere?
Often because you've been fitting in rather than belonging. Fitting in is a skill: you study a group, pick up its words and habits, and offer back a version of yourself that will pass. The catch is that the version who passes gets the welcome, while the one who did the studying stays outside, watching it arrive.
Some of this needs a doctor before it needs an article. If the feeling comes with low mood that has lasted for weeks, a fear of being judged strong enough to keep you away from people, or thoughts of harming yourself, the section on seeing a doctor further down comes first. If you're in crisis, contact your local emergency services.
And sometimes the feeling is simply accurate. If a group keeps you at arm's length because of where you're from, your faith, your body or anything else about who you are, the problem sits with the group. No amount of fitting in is your job there.
There's a free masterclass of mine called Who Am I?, which turns to the person underneath all the fitting in. It ends with a guided session, so one caution comes ahead of the link. If you've known stretches of feeling unreal or detached from your own life, or a doctor is treating you for that, ask them before the guided part, or leave it out. Anyone can stop it partway, open their eyes, plant both feet on the ground and ring someone they trust. It's free with the code GIFT26: Receive the Masterclass. Or read on.
How does fitting in cost you yourself?
Through small trades, each one sensible on its own. A laugh offered before you've found anything funny. An opinion held back because the room seems to lean the other way. Food ordered, words used, clothes chosen because they match. Each trade buys a little more welcome.
Over months, the welcome grows, and the person receiving it gets harder to find.
Giedre's four seasons were a trade of exactly that kind. They bought her the joke. They also taught her, without anyone saying a word, that the woman who turned up in April wasn't quite enough to sit by that fire as she was.
What you end up with is a place that has been earned rather than given. Earned places need keeping up. So the fitting in never quite stops, and under all the effort runs a faint sense of being on probation wherever you go.
Where does the outsider feeling start?
For many people, early. A child who changed schools often learned to read a new playground fast. A child whose home sounded different from the homes of classmates learned to keep that part quiet. A child teased once for liking the wrong thing learned to check what the right thing was before saying anything at all. These are examples, not a reading of anyone's childhood, yours included.
Each of those children found that a careful version of themselves was welcomed more easily than the one who first walked in. So they got good at the careful version. For a young person in those rooms, that made good sense, and it often kept them out of trouble.
In a city where plenty of people have arrived from somewhere else, the same skill can get a great deal of practice.
The careful versions were laid on one room at a time, and whoever walked into the first of those rooms is still there underneath.
If the version who passes tends to show up as a bright voice and a smile that won't switch off, why do I feel like I'm wearing a mask stays with that moment. If what you keep chasing is the nod that says you're welcome, how to stop seeking validation looks at that hunger.
Is it wrong to want to fit in?
No. Wanting a place among people is about as human as it gets, and adapting to a group is often a kindness: learning a few words of a colleague's language, keeping to a host's customs at their table, watching a show because someone you care about loves it.
The difference lies in whether you can come back. Adjusting to a room, then returning to yourself on the drive home, is ordinary. Adjusting so often, and so far, that you've lost the way back is where the not-belonging tends to begin.
None of this means you should stop adapting, or march into every group insisting on yourself. What helps is to notice which of your adjustments are chosen, and which ones run before you've had a chance to choose.
When does not belonging call for a doctor?
Feeling that you don't fit is common, and it isn't a diagnosis. Some versions of it belong with a professional, though, and it's worth knowing which.
See a doctor or a mental health professional if a fear of being watched or judged makes you avoid people, shops, work or study, or arrives with a racing heart, shaking or panic. The same goes if feeling apart comes with low mood that hasn't lifted for weeks, losing interest in things you used to enjoy, changes in sleep or appetite, or a sense of watching your life from outside. A doctor can listen, ask the right questions and tell you what's going on, and asking is a sensible step, never a defeat.
If you have thoughts of harming yourself, or you're in crisis, contact your local emergency services.
Can you recall a place you belonged before you tried to?
A few limits first. This is an everyday exercise in remembering, not therapy or medical care, and if a doctor or therapist is looking after you, their advice comes before anything here. Nothing in it asks you to cut back on treatment, medication or support, and if you're in recovery, your programme and the people in it carry on exactly as they are. If the doctor section above fits you today, start there instead.
The place needn't be from childhood. It can be from last year, or last month. Any place counts, as long as you were there without working at it.
- Sit somewhere comfortable with your eyes open, and give it five minutes. A chair by a window is enough.
- Bring to mind one place where you were simply there. A library corner, a stretch of beach, a bench on a walk you used to take, a café table, a workshop, the back seat on a long drive. Pick one that feels safe to remember, and pass over any tied to a painful time.
- Recall three ordinary details. Something you could see, something you could hear, and what your hands were doing.
- Notice what you weren't doing there. Checking how you came across. Rehearsing a line. Waiting for someone's nod.
- Come back to the room. Name two things you can see now, and carry on with your day.
If no place comes, stop there. Plenty of people find this hard, and an empty search says nothing about you. If remembering stirs up something painful, set it aside and reach your doctor or someone you trust.
A place like that asked nothing of you, which is partly why it slips from memory so easily.
When does the masterclass make sense after a piece like this?
The Who Am I? masterclass fits best if three things are true for you.
- The question under the fitting in is the one you're curious about. The page speaks to readers who sense something steady beneath "the plans, the worries, the identity", and it turns from the roles and history people usually give when asked who they are to the one doing the asking.
- Some time alone with it suits you. It comes in three parts: something to read, something to watch, and a guided session of about twenty minutes. The page suggests headphones and a stretch of time nobody will interrupt. No group and no call.
- The care note near the top doesn't fit you today. If feeling unreal or detached is familiar, or you're being treated for it, your doctor comes first, and the guided part can be stopped at any moment.
USD 297 is the price shown on the page, and GIFT26 at checkout brings it down to nothing.
Belonging is a word I'd sooner use than define.
Anne, in Amazon.com's reviews of my book: "This book is so much more than a read."
Robert Simic, guiding the remembering.
P.S. If staying in the background is how you usually get through a new group, fear of being seen follows that thread further. The masterclass, free with GIFT26, is there for the question underneath it. Receive the Masterclass